Case In Point

Profanity, Threats and Disloyalty: Court of Appeal Upholds Just Cause Dismissal

Case In Point

Profanity, Threats and Disloyalty: Court of Appeal Upholds Just Cause Dismissal

Date: November 18, 2026

Can an employer still establish just cause after waiting months to dismiss an employee for serious misconduct? In some circumstances, yes. In 2551965 Ontario Ltd. v. Warkentin, the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld a trial decision finding that an employer had just cause to dismiss a former owner, despite an approximately six-month delay.

Why This Decision Matters to Employers

The decision offers employers guidance on when a delay in dismissal may amount to condonation, the higher wilful misconduct standard under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) and the treatment of prior service where a business owner sells the business and remains as an employee.

Background

The employee founded Cabin Country Realty Ltd. (Cabin), a Kenora real estate brokerage, around 1990. Effective January 1, 2017, he sold it to a company owned by two long-time employees. The share purchase agreement required Cabin to employ him as a commissioned agent and contained non-competition and non-solicitation provisions. There was no separate written employment agreement.

Months after the sale, the employee swore at Cabin’s new Broker of Record and threatened to hit him. He then posted insulting notes, some about the Broker, in a staff-accessible database. Later, he steered a Cabin client to a competing brokerage, depriving Cabin of a commission. Cabin dismissed him for cause in October 2017.

Cabin sued for breach of the restrictive covenants and interference with contractual and economic relations; the employee counterclaimed for wrongful dismissal.

Trial Decision

Just Cause Existed for Dismissal at Common Law

Applying the contextual approach, the trial judge found that the threat of violence, insulting communications and intentional conflict of interest were serious misconduct irreconcilable with continued employment. The employee’s history as former owner and mentor to the new owners did not justify a different standard. The judge stated there should be “zero tolerance for abusive language or threats of violence directed at anyone in the workplace.”

Does Delay Mean the Employer Condoned the Misconduct?

Not here. The trial judge rejected the argument that Cabin condoned the conduct by waiting about six months to dismiss. The incident occurred at the start of the first sales season under new ownership, the owners had paid heavily for a business that depended on the employee, and Cabin waited until the season ended. The new owners reasonably needed time to decide how to respond. The assessment remains highly fact-specific.

The Higher ESA Wilful Misconduct Standard Was Also Met

The trial judge also found that the employee’s verbal abuse and threat of violence constituted wilful misconduct, and that his conduct involving the competing brokerage, constituted wilful misconduct and wilful neglect of duty under O. Reg. 288/01 of the ESA. The employee was therefore not entitled to ESA termination pay or common law notice.

Prior Ownership Did Not Establish Prior Service

The trial judge held that the employee’s service began on the January 2017 sale, as there was no objective evidence of an employment relationship before then. Had just cause not been established, the judge would have awarded three months’ notice based on about 10 months of service, rather than more than 27 years.

The Non-Competition Covenant Was Unenforceable

The restrictive covenant was unenforceable as the geographic area “Northwestern Ontario” was overly broad and ambiguous.

Court of Appeal Decision

The Court of Appeal dismissed the employee’s appeal, finding no basis to interfere with the just cause finding. The Court described the argument that a separate culminating incident was required as “a repackaging of” the failed condonation argument. In any event, it found that a culminating incident occurred when the employee acknowledged before his dismissal that the parties no longer trusted one another. It also upheld the alternative notice assessment.

Key Takeaways for Employers

Serious Workplace Misconduct Can Justify Dismissal for Cause

Abusive language and threats of violence can be incompatible with continued employment, regardless of the employee’s seniority, status or prior ownership of the business.

Common Law Cause and the ESA Standard Remain Distinct

The statutory wilful misconduct standard is separate from, and higher than, common law just cause.

Delay Does Not Automatically Amount to Condonation

Six months was acceptable here given the circumstances. Employers should document reasons for any delay and avoid conduct suggesting the misconduct was forgiven.

Post-Closing Employment Arrangements Warrant Careful Attention

Such arrangements include the treatment of prior service and the enforceability of restrictive covenants where a seller stays on.

For more information about just cause dismissals, restrictive covenants or labour and employment considerations, in corporate transactions, please contact your Hicks Morley lawyer.


The article in this client update provides general information and should not be relied on as legal advice or opinion. This publication is copyrighted by Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP and may not be photocopied or reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express permission of Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP. ©