Case In Point
When Might HR and Payroll Working Files Escape a FIPPA Access Request?
Date: November 11, 2026
Durham College of Applied Arts and Technology (Re) is a recent order of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (IPC). The order confirms that routine HR and payroll working files may fall outside the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act’s (FIPPA) under s. 65(6)3 (and therefore not be subject to either the access or privacy provisions of FIPPA) where they meet the three part test for applying the section. This order gives institutions useful support when responding to access requests for such files.
Background
Durham College received a nine-part access request. The request was made by a union research officer when the union issued a Notice to Bargain and Request for Information. Part two of the request sought the “Total amount of money paid for all salaries combined for Ontario Learn courses both delivered and hosted by Durham College.”
The records at issue consisted of 12 Excel spreadsheets listing salaries paid to instructors and related information. The college prepared and used the spreadsheets between 2021 and 2024. Its Professional and Part-Time Learning (PPL) unit used them to facilitate the creation of employment contracts and administer payroll functions to meet the recordkeeping obligations under the Employment Standards Act, 2000. PPL also maintained the spreadsheets and shared them with the college’s human resources and payroll departments.
The college denied access under ss. 65(6)1–3, and the requester appealed.
The Test Under s. 65(6)3
The following elements of the exclusion under s. 65(6)3 must be met:
1. The records were collected, prepared, maintained or used by the institution or on its behalf.
2. The collection, preparation, maintenance or use was in relation to meetings, consultations, discussions or communications. There must be “some connection,” meaning more than a mere occasional or general connection.
3. These meetings, consultations, discussions or communications are about labour relations or employment-related matters in which the institution has an interest. “Employment related matters” are human resources or staff relations issues arising from the employer-employee relationship outside collective bargaining, and the institution’s “interest” refers to matters involving its own workforce.
The Decision
The adjudicator dismissed the appeal, upholding the college’s decision to deny access to the spreadsheets. Deciding solely under s. 65(6)3, the adjudicator adopted the same approach that was taken in the IPC orders cited by the college (Orders PO-2791 and PO-3456-I), which addressed similar circumstances and records.
The adjudicator found that all three elements were met because PPL prepared, maintained and used the spreadsheets to communicate with human resources and payroll about instructor contracts, compensation, hours and payroll.
The adjudicator confirmed that, once the exclusion applies, it continues to apply.
Key Takeaways
The order gives institutions useful support when responding to access requests for routine HR and payroll working files
Where they meet the three part test for applying s. 65(6)3, routine HR and payroll working files may not be subject to either the access or privacy provisions of FIPPA.
Prior IPC orders can be critical in providing support for submissions
The adjudicator adopted the approach in Orders PO-2791 and PO-3456-I, which treated records about hours, compensation, salary and contract information as employment-related matters, underlining the importance of institutions identifying and relying upon comparable orders.
The exclusion has limits
The Order in this case addressed payroll spreadsheets but not all labour/employment related expenditures may be found to meet the exclusion criteria. For example, the Order notes that accounting documents detailing an institution’s expenditures on legal and other services related to collective bargaining negotiations have been found not to have “some connection” to labour relations, because accountability for public expenditures is a core focus of freedom of information legislation. A figure drawn from financial records may therefore be treated differently.
The exclusion does not prevent disclosure
The exclusion removes records from FIPPA‘s access regime (as well as the rest of FIPPA including the privacy provisions). It does not prohibit disclosure, and institutions can still disclose excluded records outside FIPPA. The Order does not consider disclosure obligations arising from the collective bargaining relationship, which operate independently of FIPPA. College access and privacy coordinators should consult human/resources and labour relations personnel in cases involving labour and employment records where necessary to understand the context surrounding such documents for the potential application of the exclusion and to ensure full understanding of access obligations which may flow from other sources in order to ensure appropriate responses.
If you have questions about a FIPPA access request, please contact Courtney March or a member of the Hicks Morley Information, Data & Privacy group.
The article in this client update provides general information and should not be relied on as legal advice or opinion. This publication is copyrighted by Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP and may not be photocopied or reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express permission of Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP. ©
